Technology is speeding ahead at a dizzying rate
Mobile apps like Google Translate have revolutionized how we attempt to jump over language barriers, essentially allowing us to carry around mini translators in our pockets.
Language teachers everywhere may tremble at the idea of language learning becoming obsolete, but do modern-day trends indicate that technology is eliminating the need to learn languages?
What does this imply for the future of language learning and communication?
Technological advances in translation
No longer are we limited to communicating via hand gestures when ordering coffee in foreign countries.
All we have to do is speak into our phones to get an admittedly imperfect but usable translation, good enough to get us out in a pinch.
Technology sometimes fails us, though.
Although the quality of translation apps is improving more and more each day, the translations that they spit back out at us are sometimes downright strange.
The collection of awkwardly (sometimes humorously) translated texts you can find on the internet epitomizes the phrase “lost in translation.”
Although translation tools are beneficial, over-reliance on them certainly isn’t the most effective course of action.
But technology is continuously improving:
- Will we ever reach the point where these translation apps will be practically flawless?
- Will we ever be able to rely on them as a replacement for language learning confidently?
Waverly Labs recently launched the prototype version of the “Pilot,” an in-ear translation device that reportedly translates conversations from one language to another in real-time through speech recognition and machine translation technology.
For now, it is only available in five languages, but who knows how far this innovative technology will advance?
Other companies are also jumping on this bandwagon.
Google recently developed the “Pixel Buds,” a wireless headset translator, and Skype has offered an app capable of translating in real-time. Who’s to say these first brave steps won’t launch an international revolution in how we communicate?
Limitations of translation technology
As helpful as this technology is, it is no replacement for brainwork.
Many of us may remember our math teachers telling us that a calculator can only do so much.
We can’t mindlessly punch numbers into it and expect accurate answers 100% of the time.
What if we mistype a number or fail to press the plus sign down?
It is a helpful tool, but it is no replacement for knowledge and logic.
In the end,
➤ we always have to estimate a ballpark figure mentally
➤ to evaluate whether the result the calculator gives us is accurate.
The same goes for translation apps. Technology sometimes fails.
There is no way around it. Weak wi-fi connections and phone glitches happen. Translation apps are still not as proficient as we need them to be.
What will we do when technology falls short? Will our brains know what is necessary to fill in the gaps?
The limitations of translation technology are compounded by the fact that language is exceptionally malleable, subjective, dependent on regional characteristics, and constantly evolving.
Language is never an exact science. No matter how advanced they may be, technological heuristics may never be able to mimic and replace the complexity of our minds.
Translation apps may sometimes translate idioms too literally, failing to capture the intended meaning.
They cannot also consider regional linguistic differences.
- A particular French word, for example.
- It may have several different meanings and usages in just one region of France.
- So, place that word against the linguistic background of other French-speaking countries in Africa.
- And you might find that it has an entirely different set of meanings.
- Will translation apps ever be able to control for these variables?
➤ If we ask a German-speaking friend, for example:
➤ what the German translation of a specific word would be
➤ we might get an avalanche of questions in response rather than a single word:
- What exactly are you trying to say?
- What is the context?
- Who would you be saying this to?
- What emotion do you want to convey?
Translation apps cannot ask for this sort of crucial feedback from us.
In truth, the translation of a single word is usually not cut and dried.
Several factors come into play when selecting the most appropriate translation.
Benefits of speaking multiple languages
⤷ We might assume that technology is leading us away from language learning by favoring automated translation, but it is also (perhaps surprisingly) providing more and more language learning tools.
⤷ If we assume automatic translation and language learning are on opposite ends of the spectrum, we might think technology leans one way or another.
⤷ But, in reality, we are finding that technology is branching off in both directions.
Just as it has never been easier to instantly bridge language gaps through translation software, it has never been easier to harness the power of technology to learn a language.
How is that?
➤ Introducing an innovative, immersion-based method that moves away from traditional book learning and motivates us to learn intuitively in a fun way.
The jury is still out regarding the effectiveness of this method:
- While it might not be the “end-all, be-all” replacement for boring grammar drills,
- it is undoubtedly a tool that can enhance our ability to pick up on a foreign language.
And why shouldn’t technology favor language learning as well as automated translation?
We can have it both ways; they are not mutually exclusive.
Research has demonstrated that the cognitive benefits of speaking multiple languages are immense.
➤ It has been proven that multilingual speakers show a higher processing speed than monolinguals while completing specific mental tasks.
➤ Speaking several languages may enhance creative flexibility as well.
➤ Our society’s reality shapes language and, in turn, that language shapes the way we think ➤ , so it is logical to conclude that:
Speaking more than one language allows us to:
See things from various perspectives and
find more creative, innovative solutions to problems.
➤ Sometimes we find that one word we so desperately need to express what we’re feeling precisely only exists in another language.
Emotions, which are notoriously abstract and challenging to communicate, are particularly subject to this phenomenon.
Take the Portuguese word “saudade,” for example, which refers to ➤
the profound nostalgia we might feel knowing that the thing or person we miss may never return again
How can a single word capture the intensity and dimensionality of a feeling that requires so many words to express in English?
Are we willing to renounce the mental richness of gleaning these tidbits of gold from other languages?
The same applies to words that have become obsolete in our own language.
Take the word “apricity,” for instance, a 1620s term that refers to ➤
that glorious warmth of the sun on a cold winter’s day
How have we gone for centuries without this gem of a word?
The depth that comes from language learning, whether learning a new language or studying yours more deeply, is irreplaceable.
- So, why don’t we find a compromise?
- Rather than rooting for automated translation or language learning, why don’t we tap into the best of both worlds?
- Why don’t we use translation apps to enhance our language learning efforts instead of using them as replacements?